How Adoption Advertising Fuels Adoption Trafficking in the United States: A Step-by-Step Breakdown

Domestic Adoption Trafficking

We recently received a call from a family who had previously adopted through our agency. They shared a concerning situation involving an adoption agency in Wichita, Kansas. This agency had reached out to them about assisting a young mother who had just left the hospital and needed funds to travel from Indiana to Kansas to give her baby up for adoption. The family asked us, “Is this normal? Is it even legal?” With nearly three decades of experience in adoption, we can say this practice isn’t uncommon. It’s time to address it directly – this is “Domestic Adoption Trafficking.” This article is long overdue. I am surprised that other ethical adoption professionals have not highlighted this issue more often. Most discussions about adoption trafficking focus on international cases. In those situations, children are trafficked into the United States for adoption. It follows that if some adoption professionals were involved in international adoption trafficking, there are individuals and organizations skilled at trafficking birth mothers across state lines. They bypass local and federal laws to influence women to give their babies up for adoption under duress. We will break down how “Domestic Adoption Trafficking” occurs, the laws it violates, and the tactics used. These tactics include fraud, coercion, exploitation, and deception to manipulate women considering adoption into relocating.

Laws Regulating Adoption Advertising and Adoption Services

Many states have laws regulating who can legally advertise and perform adoption services, specifically requiring only legally licensed agencies or attorneys within the state to perform any adoption services. Rather than covering all these states, we’ll focus on Indiana, where A Bond of Life Adoptions is licensed and where we are familiar with the laws governing adoption advertising, adoption services, and legally managing the adoption process.

Indiana Code (IC) 35-46-1-21 Unauthorized Adoption Advertising

Sec. 21. (a) As used in this section, “advertisement” means any communication by any medium within the borders of Indiana, including print advertisements, digital advertisements, radio, television, and outdoor advertising signs.

(b) Except as provided in subsection (d), only a person that is an attorney licensed to practice law in Indiana or a child placing agency licensed under the laws of Indiana may place an advertisement that:

(1) a child is offered or wanted for adoption; or

(2) the person is able to place, locate, or receive a child for adoption.

(c) A person who knowingly or intentionally violates subsection (b) commits unauthorized adoption advertising, a Level 6 felony.

IC 35-46-1-21 is clear. In Indiana, only advertisements from Indiana-licensed adoption agencies or licensed attorneys are allowed for adoption. However, if you search for “How to Put My Baby Up for Adoption,” you won’t find many legal ads. Search engine results show that 80% to 100% of paid ads and search engine content come from non-licensed entities. This situation puts vulnerable birth mothers in a difficult position. They are left with primarily illegal and unlicensed options when seeking adoption help during a crisis pregnancy.     

IC 35-46-1-22 Unauthorized Adoption Facilitation

This law contains a long list of adoption services that only an Indiana-licensed Adoption Agency or an Indiana-licensed attorney may perform in the state of Indiana. Any entity that is not licensed in Indiana and provides any adoption services to a birth mother living in Indiana commits unauthorized adoption facilitation, which carries criminal penalties under the statute.

In Indiana, you must have a license to place an adoption advertisement and to provide adoption services. This law is important. If these laws are violated, the adoption entity faces criminal charges. It does not matter if a paid ad is placed. If a birth mother finds an adoption entity through unpaid search engine content, it is still illegal. Only Indiana licensed entities can provide services to a birth mother.

The Adoption Industry’s Marketing Tactics

Domestic Adoption Trafficking often begins where most searches do – on popular search engines. These platforms become the first stop for expectant parents or birth mothers who have already given birth and are looking into adoption options.

The adoption industry’s marketing approach uses aggressive online strategies. They target expectant parents in crisis, often disregarding laws to reach those who may be easily swayed. These methods are unethical and illegal and lead to the exploitation of birth mothers through pressure, deceit, and duress.

Aggressive online advertising strategies that break the law

There are two ways to provide illegal adoption services in Indiana and other states: through paid ads and through search content that targets birth parents in areas where it is not legal to advertise or give adoption services unless you are licensed. Below distinguishes different ways a prospective birth mother may reach out for adoption services

  • Paid Ads: A Company bids on keywords where it wants its ads to appear when someone types a search query. The ads show up as paid ads. The advertiser can select the states, cities, or zip codes in which they want their ad to appear.
  • Search-generated content: Companies or individuals put content on their websites to rank in the search engine’s organic results, such as non-paid search content results and featured snippets. The search engines’ algorithms rank these according to the search query.
  • AI-Generated Content: This type of content uses generative AI that learns patterns and structures from data it is trained on and uses that to create results.

Paid Ads

The advertiser directly controls paid Ads.

Adoption facilitators and non-licensed agencies use aggressive, illegal online advertising to attract and mislead potential birth mothers in states where such ads are prohibited. In paid ads, the advertiser controls the exact wording of headlines. Some unlicensed entities place ads like:

  • “Pregnant? Considering Adoption in Indiana?”
  • “Free Adoption Services in Indiana”
  • “Indiana Adoption – Get Help Now”

Most of these ads lead to out-of-state agencies, attorneys, or facilitators not licensed in Indiana. They might offer money, relocation, and housing that deceive and lure the birth mother into believing they are working with a reputable legal local adoption professional and use the tactics to coerce the birth mother to relocate. Search engines provide a platform for felonious advertisers to misrepresent themselves and get to birth mothers who need reliable legal adoption services and make them targets to be trafficked and forced to give a baby up for adoption.

Organic Search

Organic search refers to the results shown for a search query that excludes paid ads. The main difference between paid search and organic search is that paid search results are paid for and populated via an auction system. In contrast, organic search results are unpaid and decided by search engine ranking algorithms. Most of the time, there are three types of organic search results directed by the search engine ranking algorithms: AI-generated, Structured Snippets, and General Search Results. Search engines have policies to provide the search user with trustworthy, reliable results that protect users from harmful and illegal content. But on a search in Indiana about “How to Give a Baby Up for Adoption,” you may not find any legally licensed results generated by the search or paid ads on the first page, leaving a birthmother with an 80% to 100% chance of reaching out to an entity that is committing a crime by advertising and providing adoption services to a birth mother in Indiana. This is where the search engine policies claim responsibility to the user by following laws governed by where a search is generated but are producing options that guarantee she may never contact a legally licensed Indiana adoption agency or a legally licensed attorney.

Enticing Expectant or New Mothers to Another State

When a birthmother responds to an illegal ad or search content, the unlawful adoption provider often tries to relocate her to their preferred state. They may promise more money, gifts, or freedom from dealing with the child’s biological father. The goal is to separate the mother from her support system, giving the unlawful entity control over her adoption process. How common is this? One adoption agency email stated, “We work with birthmothers all over the country, and about 70% come here to deliver.” Consider the following ad from an illegal paid ad placed in Indiana and its trafficking-like elements:

Sponsored

Adoption in Indiana – Pregnant Need Help?

We pay all living costs & help relocate. Completely Confidential. Open or closed adoption. Choose Adoption. Free, safe housing for you & your family. Call Today. Free Housing. Free Adoption Housing. Bills Paid

Understanding Birthmother Relocation/Trafficking

Domestic Adoption Trafficking traps a birthmother in a state where her only support comes from the group that illegally advertised and illegally provided adoption services in her home state. The process began with unethical players, leaving her with a support system focused solely on one goal: giving up her baby for adoption, no matter what. What happens if the birthmother changes her mind about adoption? The adoption agency, facilitator, or attorney then increases the pressure. “That’s okay. You can change your mind, but you must pay back all the money you’ve received and cover your travel home.” Many birthmothers consider adoption due to financial struggles and lack of funds. Predators exploit this, manipulating them under duress to give up their babies. The baby becomes the mother’s currency to get home, and her only option is to give away their baby to get home.

Avoiding the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children (ICPC)

ICPC is a federal law that oversees the movement of children across state lines. It applies to all 50 states to protect children in interstate adoptions. ICPC reviews the laws in both the sending state (where the birth mother lives or the baby is born) and the receiving state (where the adoptive family and child will live). Licensed adoption agencies or attorneys must submit paperwork to ICPC to ensure both states’ laws are followed. These ICPC packages include the child’s medical records, adoption paperwork, and court proceeding status. Many illegal adoption advertisers who unlawfully engage with birthmothers bypass federal laws and ICPC supervision by moving pregnant women to give up their babies in one state, avoiding ICPC notification. A Utah Law Center even has an article titled “Adopting a Child from Outside Utah – Avoiding ICPC,” outlining ways to skip ICPC oversight. They suggest moving the child’s mother to Utah to finalize the adoption there, even stating, “Adoption Agencies frequently pay to have birth mothers come to Utah for labor and delivery.” Why? In our 28 years of adoption experience at A Bond of Life Adoptions, we’ve never needed to move a birth mother from her state of residence.

Preventing Birth Fathers from Establishing Parental Rights

When adoption is performed legally, state-licensed adoption agencies or state-licensed adoption attorneys must follow state laws to allow the birth father to establish his parental rights. The trafficker knows there is a high likelihood that the potential biological father will reside in the birth mother’s state of residence. Each state has legal requirements that must be met to locate a possible biological father, such as notice of court proceedings, checking the state’s putative father registry, or the court assigning a curator to try and locate the father. The putative father registry is an essential tool in this process. Currently, at least 24 states have a putative father registry, which allows men to claim paternity and protect their parental rights. Legally Licensed adoption professionals must check this registry to see if a putative father is registered. However, it only has to be checked in the state where the baby is born or placed for adoption. For example, if a baby is born in Indiana, the putative father registry is checked in Indiana by licensed adoption professionals for potential fathers. But, if the birth mother is trafficked from Indiana to Arizona, then the putative father registry only has to be checked in Arizona. So then, the only way a father can use the putative father registry to protect his parental rights is to sign up for the putative father registry in Arizona. How would a biological father know he has to sign up for a putative father registry in a state he or the birth mother has never been to? What the adoption trafficker knows is that if a father finds out their baby was given up for adoption without his knowledge in another state, by the time he attempts to stop it, the time limit to contest the adoption has usually expired. They cannot bring a case in the State where the birth mother was trafficked too.

Conclusion

Adoption trafficking often happens in the U.S., set up by false advertising, manipulation, deception, fraud, and coercion committed by adoption entities that are committing crimes to get to birth mothers. These tricks are meant to make a birth mother more likely to give up her baby for adoption. Birth mothers, especially those with money problems, can be easily taken advantage of by illegal adoption agencies, lawyers, and facilitators.

This article isn’t against adoption. It’s against adoption trafficking. The issue lies with unethical adoption facilitators, agencies, and lawyers who break state laws, ignoring the fact they’re committing felonies. Most states have laws regulating adoption advertising and who can legally offer adoption services, aiming to ensure ethical oversight of adoptions to ensure the best interests of the mother, the child, and the adoptive parents. These laws exist, but enforcement from state attorney generals, prosecutors, and licensing bodies is non-existent. The logical first step to curb adoption trafficking is for search engines to enforce their policies, ensuring transparent, reliable, and legal search content in paid ads and search results.

Birth mothers and birth fathers deserve better. Not everyone contacting an adoption professional needs to place their baby for adoption. With proper information, they can make informed, confident decisions that serve their and their baby’s best interests. This also gives adoptive parents peace of mind, knowing their adoption followed all applicable laws. However, if a birth mother responds to an illegal ad and is moved far from home, dependent on unethical individuals, she loses her choice and must give up her baby to escape her situation.

Scroll to Top

Get Adoption Help Now

Our team of caring, experienced adoption experts are here for you 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Due Date
Select One